home *** CD-ROM | disk | FTP | other *** search
- <text id=94TT1309>
- <title>
- Sep. 26, 1994: Music:The Mating Game
- </title>
- <history>
- TIME--The Weekly Newsmagazine--1994
- Sep. 26, 1994 Taking Over Haiti
- </history>
- <article>
- <source>Time Magazine</source>
- <hdr>
- ARTS & MEDIA/MUSIC, Page 74
- The Mating Game
- </hdr>
- <body>
- <p> A sparkling new opera based on Les Liaisons Dangereuses delivers
- a morality tale about the machinations of love
- </p>
- <p>By Michael Walsh
- </p>
- <p> From Mozart's Don Giovanni to Stravinsky's The Rake's Progress,
- the figure of the libertine, that politically incorrect swine,
- has swaggered provocatively through 200 years of operatic history.
- Cads, bounders and rakehells abound onstage: one thinks not
- only of the lecherous Don and Tom Rakewell but of Nerone, Pinkerton
- and Eugene Onegin as well--moral reprobates who give hardly
- a second thought to the consequences of their actions.
- </p>
- <p> Now comes the composer-librettist team of Conrad Susa and Philip
- Littell, who have seized upon Pierre Choderlos de Laclos's 18th
- century epistolary novel Les Liaisons Dangereuses as a fitting
- subject for an opera. It is an inspired choice: in the machinating
- Marquise de Merteuil and the voluptuary Vicomte de Valmont the
- composer has two soulless soul mates whose knowledge of the
- ways of love make The Art of War look like a kindergarten training
- manual. What Susa and Littell have created in The Dangerous
- Liaisons, now getting its world premiere at the San Francisco
- Opera, is nothing short of wonderful: a finely wrought near
- masterpiece that ennobles its characters with music that comes
- not from the head but from the heart--hating the sin of licentiousness,
- but loving the sinner, as all good operas do.
- </p>
- <p> Familiar from its various stage and cinematic incarnations,
- Liaisons, sung in English, is an extravagant chess match of
- check and mate--and mate and mate. The Marquise (mezzo Frederica
- von Stade, in top form) is an archmanipulator who wields her
- sensual allure like a double-edged sword, encouraging her lover's
- worst instincts as she wreaks her revenge on society. Her foil,
- the unapologetic knave Valmont (the splendid baritone Thomas
- Hampson), is a cynical womanizer who makes the fatal mistake
- of falling in love with one of his victims, unwisely and too
- well. Who is worse? The amoral rake who seduces and abandons
- without remorse? Or the wily temptress who sends her dark knight
- on errant missions of the heart? In this telling, the two protagonists
- not only are equally responsible, they deserve each other, and
- their fate.
- </p>
- <p> Susa, 59, a painstaking composer probably best known for his
- delightful 1973 opera Transformations, was delivering orchestrations
- right up to the dress rehearsal, but the seams don't show. From
- first note to last, Liaisons is a finely polished work that
- achieves a French transparency, sparingly invoking Debussy (not
- Pelleas but Images pour Orchestre). Unabashedly tonal, although
- hardly reactionary, the score glows with a luminescence too
- long absent from modern opera, and especially opera in English;
- for an equal, one must go back to Britten's Death in Venice
- (1973), which Liaisons resembles musically in many small ways.
- </p>
- <p> The biggest deficiency, and it is a serious one, is that Susa
- never quite delivers the musical climax that the material demands.
- It is quite canny to stage simultaneously the death of Valmont
- and his inamorata, Madame de Tourvel, aptly illustrating their
- bond beyond the grave. But here, and in the final scene, when
- Merteuil is snubbed, shunned and ruined by the pox, the music
- needs to be bolder, richer; the composer must make clear exactly
- how he feels about what has happened to his characters as, say,
- Berg does at the end of Wozzeck.
- </p>
- <p> Colin Graham's production, which will be telecast nationally
- over PBS on Oct. 17, is simple but handsome, relying on mirrors
- and projections to make its effects. Notable performances by
- the mostly American cast include Renee Fleming's poignant Tourvel,
- Mary Mills' tender Cecile (the 15-year-old girl "ruined" by
- Valmont's depredations) and Johanna Meier's stately Madame de
- Rosemonde, Valmont's doting aunt. In the pit, Scottish-born
- Donald Runnicles leads with authority.
- </p>
- <p> In sum, this is another in a series of strong American opera
- premieres during the past few years, which has also included
- Philip Glass's The Voyage and William Bolcom's McTeague. San
- Francisco Opera general director Lotfi Mansouri speaks of sharing
- Liaisons with the Lyric Opera of Chicago and taking McTeague
- in return; it is an excellent idea, for both works merit second
- and third productions, and not just in this country.
- </p>
- <p> American composers, it seems, have rediscovered a few simple
- principles that their European counterparts, still symbolically
- poking their fingers in the eye of audiences while happily enjoying
- their government subsidies, have forgotten. The human voice
- is attached to a living being; it is not a mechanical instrument.
- It has a well-defined range within which it (and the listener)
- is most comfortable; and it is best suited to singing stepwise
- melodies rather than tunes that leap crazily all over the scale,
- except for dramatic effect. Honoring these principles is not
- pandering; it is professionalism, and The Dangerous Liaisons
- is its glorious expression.
- </p>
-
- </body>
- </article>
- </text>
-
-